How the Rent vs. Buy Calculation Works
The decision to rent or buy a home is rarely as simple as comparing a monthly mortgage payment to a monthly rent check. Doing so ignores the two most powerful variables in personal finance: unrecoverable ownership costs and the opportunity cost of capital.
When you purchase a home, a significant portion of your monthly payment is permanently lost to non-equity expenses: mortgage interest, municipal property taxes, homeowners insurance, and routine structural maintenance. Simultaneously, locking up a $90,000 down payment in home equity prevents those funds from compounding in broad-market index funds (such as the S&P 500).
Understanding Unrecoverable Costs (The 5% Rule)
Popularized by portfolio manager Ben Felix, the 5% Rule breaks down the ongoing unrecoverable costs of residential property into three distinct categories:
- Property Taxes (~1%): Municipal real estate taxes paid annually without building equity.
- Maintenance & Depreciation (~1%): Replacing roofs, HVAC units, water heaters, and general repairs (standard rule of thumb is 1% of property value per year).
- Cost of Capital (~3%): The spread between mortgage debt interest and the expected real return of equities, reflecting the opportunity cost of down payment equity.
Multiplying a home's purchase price by 5% and dividing by 12 yields the monthly breakeven rent. If you can rent an equivalent home for less than this number, renting and investing the surplus cash builds more net worth.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many years do you need to stay in a home to break even? ▾
In most U.S. metropolitan markets under current 6.5% to 7% mortgage rates, the typical breakeven period ranges between 4 and 7 years. Because closing costs (2% to 4% at purchase) and selling broker fees (5% to 6% at sale) total roughly 8% to 10% in friction costs, moving sooner almost always results in a net financial loss compared to renting.
Does home appreciation make buying automatically superior? ▾
Historically, residential real estate in the United States appreciates at roughly 3.5% to 4.5% per year (matching long-term inflation). Over the same 100-year period, diversified equity index funds like the S&P 500 have compounded at approximately 9.8% to 10% annualized. While leverage (borrowing 80% on a mortgage) boosts real estate returns, high borrowing costs offset that advantage unless held over long horizons.