R
RentVsBuyCalc.net
← Back to Guides

Renting & Investing the Difference

Published by RentVsBuyCalc.net Research Desk • 6 min read

The Core Premise

A renter who diligently invests their down payment capital and monthly housing cash savings in low-cost index funds often matches or beats homeowner equity.

Over 100 years, the S&P 500 has averaged roughly 10% nominal annual returns, compared to roughly 3.5%–4.5% nominal price appreciation for residential real estate.

The Down Payment Opportunity Cost

Putting 20% down on a $500,000 home requires $100,000 in cash, plus approximately $12,500 in non-refundable closing costs.

If that $112,500 remains invested in a low-cost total stock market index fund compounding at a conservative 7.5% real return:

  • After 10 Years: That $112,500 grows to approximately $231,800 without adding another penny.
  • After 20 Years: It compounds to approximately $477,800.
  • After 30 Years: It surpasses $984,800 in liquid, dividend-producing wealth.

Homebuyers often overlook this lost compounding because home equity feels tangible, even though equity trapped inside a primary residence produces zero cash flow until the home is sold or refinanced.